Page 1 of 1

Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 10:03 am
by Ben_Gosu

Hello,

I've been searching all over the internet for an answer to this, but it seems it doesn't happen to often and nobody talks about it.

I had a ticket for driving alone in the HOV lane (2+ passengers). I went to trial and in the end the judge said my explanation was not valid and the charges stand. I submitted some doctor's notes as evidence that they kept (as part of my defense was that I wasn't feeling well after a surgery and hesitated in what became HOV lane from another highway). I was confused in the end and asked "so how much do I have to pay and are there any demerit points" and the judge answered "I don't know about the demerit points, blah blah, it's the MTC's jurisdiction - but you don't have to pay anything - I AM SUSPENDING THE TRIAL"

Now...what does that exactly mean?... Am I still convicted, can my insurance still go up, or everything is scratched off by this "suspended trial"? Is the suspension permanent or temporary?

Any advise is greatly appreciated, thanks.


Re: Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 10:45 am
by Stanton

I'm thinking you were given a suspended sentence. You were found guilty, but there is no fine.


Re: Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 1:48 pm
by Ben_Gosu

That's what I think as well: there is a conviction, but it's suspended. I understand there is no fine, what I don't know though is if the demerit points got applied and most important if it goes on my record and so my insurance would go up.

Thanks again.


Re: Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Fri May 18, 2012 10:05 am
by Simon Borys

Ben_Gosu wrote:That's what I think as well: there is a conviction, but it's suspended. I understand there is no fine, what I don't know though is if the demerit points got applied and most important if it goes on my record and so my insurance would go up.


If you received a suspended sentence (i.e. $0 fine) then there is a conviction, just no punishment. It is NOT that the conviction itself is suspended. Since there is a conviction there are points. They automatically accompany the conviction, regardless of whether there was a fine or not. Insurance is affected by whether there was a conviction or not, NOT by whether there was a fine or not.


Re: Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Sun May 27, 2012 12:20 pm
by skywalker12

Simon Borys - I heard that in Ontario the demerit points are calculated based on the $$ amount of the fine. not by the infraction type. (however some infractions are usually having high $$ amount and therefore fall under the high demerit points category).


Can you confirm or deny that?


Re: Trial Supended By Judge - What Does It Mean?

Posted: Sun May 27, 2012 12:22 pm
by skywalker12

Never mind, I just checked and it is based on specific offences, not on the $$ amount of the fine.


Please ignore my previous post.